Process-oriented
syllabuses
Introduction
In 3 we looked at
syllabuses in which the focus was on the grammatical, functional, and notional
building blocks out of which courses of various types can be constructed.
Initially, it seemed that functional-notional principles would result in
syllabuses which were radically different from those based on grammatical
principles. I Iowever, in practice, the new syllabuses were rather similar to
those they were intended to replace. In both syllabuses, the focus tended to
be on the end products or results of the
teaching/learning process.
We saw that
syllabuses in which the selection and grading of items was carried out on a
grammatical basis fell into disfavour because they failed adequately to reflect
changing views on the nature of language.
In addition, there was sometimes a mismatch
between what was taught and what was learned.
Some SLA researchers have claimed that this mismatch is likely to occur when the grading of syllabus input is carried out according to grammatical
rather than psycholinguistic principles, while others suggest that the very act of linguistically selecting and grading
input will lead to distortion.
Procedural syllabuses
Despite some
differences in
practice, the principles underlying procedural
and task-based syllabuses are very si milar. In
fact, they are seen as synonymous by Richards,
Platt, and Weber (1985), who describe them
both as follows:
... a syllabus which
is organised around tasks, rather than in terms of grammar or vocabulary. For example
the syllabus may suggest a variety of different kinds of tasks which the
learners are expected to carry out in the language, such as using the telephone
to obtain information; drawing maps based on oral instructions; performing actions
based on commands given in the target language; giving orders and instructions
to others, etc. It has been argued that this is a more effective way of
learning a language since it provides a purpose for the use and learning of a language
other than simply learning language items for their own sake. (Richards,
Platt, and Weber 1985: 289) Both task-based and procedural
syllabuses share a concern with the
classroom processes
which stimulate learning. They therefore differ from syllabuses in which the
focus is on the linguistic items that students will learn or the communicative skills that they will be able to
display as a result of instruction. In both approaches, the syllabus consists,
not of a list
of items determined through some form of
linguistic analysis, nor of a
description of what
learners will be able to do at the end of a course of study, but of the
specification of the tasks and activities that learners will engage in class.
Product-oriented
syllabuses
Introduction
In 2,I drew
adistinction between product-oriented and process-oriented syllabuses.
We saw that product
syllabuses are those in which the focus is on the knowledge and skills which
learners should gain as a result of instruction, while process syllabuses are
those which focus on the learning experiences themselves.
In 3, we shall look
at syllabus proposals which are specified in terms of the end products of a course
of instruction. As we shall see, these may be realized in a variety of ways,
for example as lists of grammatical items, vocabulary items, language
functions, or experiential content.
3.2 Analytic and
synthetic syllabus planning
There are many
different ways in which syllabus proposals of one sort or another might be
analysed. One dimension of analysis which has been the subject of a great deal
of discussion and comment is the synthetic/analytic dimension. It was Wilkins (1976)
who first drew attention to the distinction between synthetic and analytic
syllabuses. He described the synthetic approach in the following terms:
A synthetic language
teaching strategy is one in which the different parts of language are taught
separately and step by step so that acquisition is a process of gradual
accumulation of parts until the whole structure of language has been built up.
3.3 Grammatical
syllabuses
The most common
syllabus type was, and probably still is, one in which syllabus input is
selected and graded according to grammatical notions of simplicity and
complexity. Later in 3 we shall see that grammatical complexity does not
necessarily equate with learning difficulty. In other words, what is
grammatically complex will not necessarily be that which is difficult to learn,
and that which is grammatically simple will not necessarily be that which is
easy to learn.
One of the
difficulties in designing grammatical 'chains' in which discrete grammatical
items are linked is that the links can be rather tenuous. It is also difficult
to isolate and present one discrete item at a time, particularly if one wants
to provide some sort of context for the language.
In addition, evidence from second language acquisition (SLA ) research suggests
that learning does not occur in this simple additive fashion. "fhe dilemma
for the syllabus designer who is attempting to follow some sort of structural
progression in sequencing input is this: How does one control input and yet at
the same ti me provide language samples for the learner to work on which bear
some semblance at least to the sort of language the learner will encounter
outside the classroom? This problem might be addressed in a number of ways. One
solution would be to abandon any attempt at structural grading. Another might
be to use
the list of graded
structures, not to determine the language to which learners are exposed, but to
determine the items which will be the pedagogic focus in class. In other words,
learners would be exposed to naturalistic samples of text which were only
roughly graded, and which
provided a richer
context, but they would only be expected formally to master those items which
had been isolated, graded, and set out in the syllabus. Another alternative,
and one we shall look at in detail in 4, is to focus on what learners are
expected to do with the language (i.e. learning tasks), rather than on
the language itself. With this alternative, it is the tasks
rather than the language
which are graded.

0 komentar:
Posting Komentar